Jean-Honoré Fragonard: The New in the Notions of “Sketchiness” and “Completeness”

The second half of the 18th century was a time of active changes in the perception of art, rethinking many concepts and phenomena. One of them was the pictorial sketch, which transformed from a preparatory stadium work into an independent, complete piece of art. Many art theorists and critics, as well as painters themselves had contributed to this rethinking. Many young artists, bored of historical painting and indifferent to all the academic principles, were searching for new media of expressiveness, using the sketch-like pictorial manner to give their works a new dynamism and an impression of “easy production”. The article is dedicated to J.-H. Fragonard (1732—1806), an artist in whose works the “sketchiness” became a conscious artistic method used in small-format pieces, in large-scale canvases, and even in panels. The use of such a technique in grand scale works is considered to be an extreme unconventionality, which, however, was not appreciated by Fragonard’s contemporaries and even by scholars of the next two centuries. Fragonard’s series of ‘Fantasy Portraits’ attracted enough investigators’ attention, but his series ‘Progress of Love’ has only recently begun to be recognized by researchers as an unusual and bold for that time artistic experience. Based on the analysis of the artist’s selected works, the author builds her original research, designed to highlight Fragonard’s special role in the evolution of art on the way from the Modern Period to Contemporary History. The relevance of the present article is caused by too little examination of this topic: minimal in Russia and relatively small in France. Besides consultation with research literature, this required the author to constantly directly refer to the 18th-century sources, such as treatises by art connoisseurs and scholars, art criticism, and catalogues of exhibitions arranged by the Royal Academy of Painting and Sculpture or the Académie de Saint-Luc.

1. Les Etapes de la création: esquisses et dessins de Boucher à Isabey. Paris, 1989, 140 p.

2. L’Apothéose du geste: L’Esquisse peinte au siècle de Boucher et Fragonard: Catalogue de l’exposition. Strasbourg, Musées de Strasbourg Publ., 2003, 255 p.

3. Didro D. Salony [Salons]. Moscow, Iskusstvo Publ., 1989, vol. 1, 267 p., vol. 2, 398 p.

4. Chatelus J. Peindre à Paris aux XVIIIe siècle. Paris, 1991, 256 p.

5. Piles R. L’idée du peintre parfait (1699). Paris, Gallimard Publ., 1993, 152 p.

6. Batteux Ch. Les Beaux-Arts réduits à un principe. Paris, 1773, 329 p.

7. Caylus A.-C.-Ph., de. Dissertation lue à l’Académie de Peinture. De la légèreté d’outil, Mércure de France, 1756, September, pp. 207—226.

8. Dandré-Bardon F. Traité de peinture suivi d’un essai sur la sculpture, vol. 1. Paris, 1765, LX, 398 p.

9. Guiffrey J. Livrets des expositions de l’Académie de Saint-Luc à Paris pendant les années 1751, 1752, 1753, 1756, 1762, 1764 et 1774. Paris, Baur et Détaille Publ., 1872, 177 p.

10. Explication des peintures, sculptures et autres ouvrages de Messieurs de l’Académie royale dont l’exposition a été ordonnée, suivant l’intention de Sa Majesté, par M. de Vandière... Paris, from 1753 to 1791.

11. Jollet E. Catalogue de l’exposition “L’apothéose du geste. L’esquisse peinte au siècle de Boucher et de Fragonard”, Strasbourg, musée des Beaux-Arts (7 juin 2003 — 14 septembre 2003) et Tours, musée des Beaux-Arts (11 octobre 2003 — 11 janvier 2004), 2003, no. 24, pp. 190—193.

12. Rosenberg P. Fragonard, exposition Paris, Grand-Palais et New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art. Paris, Edition de la Réunion des Musées Nationaux Publ., 1987, 640 p.

13. Milam J. Fragonard’s Playful Paintings: Visual Games in Rococo Art. Manchester University Press Publ., 2006, 288 p.

14. Mauclair C. Fragonard. Biographie critique. Paris, Henri Laurens Publ., 1904, 132 p.

15. Percival M. Fragonard and the Fantasy Figure: Painting the Imagination. New York, Routledge Publ., 2017, 260 p.

16. Dupuy-Vaché M.-A. Fragonard: les plaisirs d’un siècle. Paris, Musée Jaquemart-André Publ., 2007—2008, 183 p.

17. Yablonskaya T.V. Klassifikatsiya portretnogo zhanra v Rossii XVIII veka: k probleme natsional’noi spetsifiki [Portrait Painting Classification in 18th Century Russia: On the Issue of National Specificity], cand. art. diss.: 17.00.04. Moscow, 1978, 205 p.

18. Mémoires secrets de Bachaumont de 1762 à 1787. Vol. 4. 1772—1774. Paris, Brissot-Thivars Publ., 1830, 452 p.

19. Renou A. Dialogues sur la peinture. Seconde édition, enrichie de notes... Paris, Tartouillis Publ., 1773—1774, 166 p.

20. Schroder A. Fragonard’s Later Career: The “Contes et Nouvelles” and the Progress of Love Revisited. The Art Bulletin, vol. 93, no. 2 (June 2011), pp. 150—177.

21. Goncourt E. et G. L’art du dix-huitième siècle, vol. 1—2. Paris, Rapilly Publ., 1873—1874, 530 p.

22. Chastel A. L’Art français. XVIIe & XVIIIe siècles. Paris, Flammarion Publ., 1995, 399 p.