The Poetry of “Heavenly Truths” by Sergei Makovsky
https://doi.org/10.25281/2072-3156-2024-21-3-312-322
Abstract
The article is devoted to the poetry of art historian Sergei Konstantinovich Makovsky (1877—1962), first considered as a self-contained phenomenon. The perception of Makovsky as a poet by contemporaries and descendants is characterized. An attempt is made to answer the question about the reasons for the general underestimation of him as a poet. Subjective metaphysical views, laid by Makovsky in the basis of his poetic creativity, are revealed. Different levels of antinomianism, characteristic of Makovsky’s general worldview and reflected in his poetic work, are analyzed. An intermediate conclusion is made that his poetry pursues the myth-making goal of merging art with religion, and the creator (poet) with the Creator (God). On the basis of the poems themselves, the persistent mystical motifs accompanying Makovsky’s poetic work are revealed and analyzed: duality, incomprehensibility, inexpressibility, silence, loneliness, horror, longing and apocalyptic perception. As a means of existentially overcoming the impact of these states, the concepts of faith, hope and love are identified. The conclusion is made about Makovsky’s non-participation in poetic movements and schools, and the relevance of his poetry at the present time is explained.
Keywords
Silver Age,
emigration,
symbolism,
poetry,
lyricism,
myth-making,
metaphysics,
mysticism,
religion,
religious culture,
artistic culture
About the Author
Nikolay N. Nosov
Russian State Library
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
3/5 Vozdvizhenka Str., Moscow, 119019, Russia
ORCID 0000-0001-6079-2677; SPIN 7786-8622
References
1. Lebedeva T.V. Sergei Makovskii. Stranitsy zhizni i tvorchestva [Sergei Makovsky. Pages of Life and Creativity]. Voronezh, Voronezhskii Universitet Publ., 2004, 484 p.
2. Shakhovskaya Z.A. Rasskazy. Stat’i. Stikhi [Stories. Articles. Poems]. Paris, Les Editeurs Reunis, 1978, 227 p.
3. Bakhrakh A.V. Po pamyati, po zapisyam. Literaturnye portrety [By Memory, by Notes. Literary Portraits]. Paris, La Presse Libre Publ., 1980, 206 p.
4. Annensky I.F. On Modern Lyricism, Apollon [Appolo], 1909, no. 2, pp. 3—29 (in Russ.).
5. Ivask Yu.P. (ed.) Na zapade: Antologiya russkoi zarubezhnoi poehzii [In the West: Anthology of Poetry of the Russian Abroad]. New York, Izdatel’stvo im. Chekhova, 1953, 398 p.
6. Kreid V. (ed.) Kovcheg: Poehziya pervoi ehmigratsii [The Ark: Poetry of the First Emigration]. Moscow, Politizdat, 1991, 511 p.
7. Vitkovsky E.V. (ed.) “My zhili togda na planete drugoi...”: Antologiya poehzii russkogo zarubezh’ya. 1920—1990. (Pervaya i vtoraya volna): V 4 kn. [“We Were Living Then on a Different Planet...”: Anthology of Poetry of the Russian Abroad. 1920—1990. (First and Second Wave): In 4 Books]. Moscow, Moskovskii Rabochii Publ., 1994, Book 1, 495 p.
8. Kreid V. (ed.) Vernut’sya v Rossiyu — stikhami...: 200 poehtov ehmigratsii: antologiya [Back to Russia in Poetry...: 200 Poets of Emigration: anthology]. Moscow, Respublika Publ., 1995, 688 p.
9. Bek T.A. (ed.) Antologiya akmeizma: Stikhi. Manifesty. Stat’i. Zametki. Memuary [Anthology of Acmeism: Poets. Manifestos. Articles. Notes. Memoirs]. Moscow, Moskovskii Rabochii Publ., 1997, 366 p.
10. Makovsky S.K. Portrety sovremennikov: Na Parnase “Serebryanogo veka”. Khudozhestvennaya kritika. Stikhi [Portraits of Contemporaries: On Parnassus of the “Silver Age”. Art Criticism. Poems]. Moscow, Agraf Publ., 2000, 768 p.
11. Makovsky S.K. Collected Poems, LibFox: electronic library. Available at: https://www.libfox.ru/565703-sergey-makovskiy-sobranie-stihotvoreniy.html (accessed 24.05.2024) (in Russ.).
12. Makovsky S.K. Portrety sovremennikov [Portraits of Contemporaries]. Moscow, XXI v. — Soglasie Publ., 2000, 445 p.
13. Makovsky S.K. Na Parnase Serebryanogo veka [On the Parnassus of the Silver Age]. Moscow, XXI v. — Soglasie Publ., 2000, 558 p.
14. Makovsky S.K. Na Parnase Serebryanogo veka [On Parnassus of the Silver Age]. Moscow, Nash Dom — L’Aged’Homme Publ., Yekaterinburg, U-Faktoriya Publ., 2000, 394 p.
15. Makovsky S.K. Siluehty russkikh khudozhnikov [Silhouettes of the Russian Artists]. Moscow, Respublika Publ., 1999, 382 p.
16. Ivask Yu.P (ed.) Opyty: literaturnyi zhurnal [Experiments: a literary journal]. New York, 1958, Book 9, 134 p.
17. Grinberg R.N., Pastukhov V.L. (eds.) Opyty: literaturnyi zhurnal [Experiments: a literary journal]. New York, 1953, Book 2, 208 p.
18. Kreid V. (ed.) Vospominaniya o Serebryanom veke [Memories of the Silver Age]. Moscow, Respublika Publ., 1993, 559 p.
19. Terapiano Yu.K. Literaturnaya zhizn’ russkogo Parizha za polveka (1924—1974): Ehsse, vospominaniya, stat’i [Literary Life of Russian Paris for Half a Century (1924—1974): Essays, Memoirs, Articles]. Paris, Al’batros Publ., New York, Tret’ya Volna Publ., 1987, 352 p.
20. Pomerantsev K.D. Skvoz’ smert’: Vospominaniya [Through Death: Memories]. London, Overseas Publications Interchange Publ., 1986, 193 p.
21. Zlobin V.A. Tyazhelaya dusha: Literaturnyi dnevnik. Vospominaniya. Stat’i. Stikhotvoreniya [Heavy Soul: Literary Diary. Memories. Articles. Poems]. Moscow, Intelvak Publ., 2004, 623 p.
22. Bryusov V.Ya. Sergei Makovsky: Collected Poems. The First Book: review, Vesy: Ezhemesyachnik iskusstv i literatury [Libra: Monthly of Arts and Literature]. Moscow, Skorpion Publ., 1905, no. 4, p. 65 (in Russ.).
23. Annenkov Yu.P. Dnevnik moikh vstrech: Tsikl tragedii [Diary of My Meetings: The Cycle of Tragedies]. New York, Mezhdunarodnoe Literaturnoe Sodruzhestvo Publ., 1966, vol. 2, 350 p.
24. Makovsky S.K. Introduction, Apollon [Apollo], 1909, no. 1, pp. 3—4 (in Russ.).
25. Makovsky S.K. Na Parnase “Serebryanogo veka” [On Parnassus of the “Silver Age”]. Munich, Izdatel’stvo Tsentral’nogo Ob”edineniya Politicheskikh Ehmigrantov iz SSSR (TSOPEH), 1962, 370 p.
26. Makovsky S.K. Stranitsy khudozhestvennoi kritiki. Kniga pervaya: Mysli i vpechatleniya o khudozhestvennom tvorchestve sovremennogo Zapada... [Pages of Art Criticism. The First Book: Thoughts and Impressions on the Artistic Creation of the Modern West]. St. Petersburg, Izdanie Sodruzhestva, Tovarishchestvo R. Golike i A. Vil’borg Publ., 1906, 183 p.
27. Makovsky S.K. (ed.) Narodnoe iskusstvo Podkarpatskoi Rusi [Folk Art of Subcarpathian Russia]. Praga, Plamya Publ., 1925, 157 p.
28. Makovsky S.K. Poslednie itogi zhivopisi [The Last Paintings]. Berlin, Russkoe Universal’noe Izdatel’stvo, 1922, 167 p.
29. Makovsky S.K. Sobranie stikhov: Kniga pervaya [Collected Poems: The First Book]. St. Petersburg, Izdanie Sodruzhestva, Tovarishchestvo R. Golike i A. Vil’borg Publ., 1905, 128 p.
30. Makovsky S.K. Requiem: Devyataya kniga stikhov [Requiem: The Ninth Book of Poems]. Paris, Rifma Publ., 1963, 75 p.
31. Mosty: literaturno-khudozhestvennyi i obshchestvenno-politicheskii al’manakh [The Bridges: Literary, Artistic and Socio-Political Almanac]. Munich, Izdatel’stvo Tsentral’nogo Ob”edineniya Politicheskikh Ehmigrantov iz SSSR (TSOPEH), 1960, Book 4, 330 p.
32. Forshteter M.A. Izbrannye stikhotvoreniya (1916—1958) [Selected Poems (1916—1958)]. Paris, Tip. Bereznyaka Publ., 1960, XXI, 69 p.
33. Mosty: literaturno-khudozhestvennyi i obshchestvenno-politicheskii al’manakh [The Bridges: Literary, Artistic and Socio-Political Almanac]. Munich, Izdatel’stvo Tsentral’nogo Ob”edineniya Politicheskikh Ehmigrantov iz SSSR (TSOPEH), 1961, Book 6, 382 p.
34. Lobanov V.M. Kanuny: Iz khudozhestvennoi zhizni Moskvy v predrevolyutsionnye gody [Canunes: From the Artistic Life of Moscow in the Pre-Revolutionary Years]. Moscow, Sovetskii Khudozhnik Publ., 1968, 296 p.
35. Makovsky S.K. Vecher: Vtoraya kniga stikhov (1918—1940) [Evening: The Second Book of Poems (1918—1940)]. Paris, 1941, 125 p.
36. Makovsky S.K. Na puti zemnom: Shestaya kniga stikhov [On the Way of the Earth: The Sixth Book of Poems]. Paris, Rifma Publ., 1953, 46 p.
37. Makovsky S.K. Somnium Breve: Stikhi: Tret’ya kniga stikhov [Somnium Breve: Poems: The Third Book of Poems]. Paris, La Presse Françaiseet Etrangère Publ., 1948, 126 p.
38. Makovsky S.K. Krug i ten’: Pyataya kniga stikhov [The Circle and the Shadow: The Fifth Book of Poems]. Paris, Rifma Publ., 1951, 46 p.
39. Makovsky S.K. V lesu: Sed’maya kniga stikhov [In the Forest: The Seventh Book of Poems]. Munich, 1956, 46 p.
40. Makovsky S.K. Eshche stranitsa: Vos’maya kniga stikhov [Another Page: The Eighth Book of Poems]. Paris, 1957, 46 p.
41. Makovsky S.K. God v usad’be: Stikhi: Chetvertaya kniga stikhov [The Year in the Estate: Poems: The Fourth Book of Poems]. Paris, 1949, 109 p.
42. Meier G.A. Sergei Makovsky and the Silver Age: (To the Anniversary of S.K. Makovsky’s Death), Grani: zhurnal literatury, iskusstva, nauki i obshchestvenno-politicheskoi mysli [Grani: a journal of literature, art, science and socio-political thought], 1963, no. 54, pp. 209—217 (in Russ.).
Review
For citations:
Nosov N.N. The Poetry of “Heavenly Truths” by Sergei Makovsky. Observatory of Culture. 2024;21(3):312-322. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.25281/2072-3156-2024-21-3-312-322
Views:
171
Email this article 