The Mimetic Crisis in René Girard’s Project of “Fundamental Anthropology”: Main Aspects

The focus of this paper is on comprehension of concepts and problems central to the theory of Franco-American philosopher and anthropologist R. Girard. Despite the recent increase of interest in the ideas of the author among Russian-speaking audience, in Russian educational community his creative heritage have not yet been sufficiently explored. The topics developed by R. Girard have a significant place in the modern science of man and society: the nature of human aggression, the origins of religious and cultural institutions, the phenomenon of crowd and the laws of imitation, the social morality. The paper aims to analyze the most important problems and concepts of R. Girard’s philosophical project (scapegoat, constituent violence, duplicity, sacrifice), focusing on the mimetic theme inside his theory. Researching various sources, from ancient literature and mythology to studies in psychology and ethology, the author of “Fundamental Anthropology” reaches the conclusion that at the basis of all social institutions lies mimetic capacity that makes human beings reproduce the actions and borrow desires of their tribesman. The “desire without object”, leading to mimetic rivalry, represents a threat to the stability of society, reflected in a risk of mimetic crisis, destabilization of moral values and “war of all against all”. According to Girard, the practice of sacrifice acts as a compensatory mechanism, so-called “pharmakon”, which helps to overcome the destructive consequences of mimesis.

1. Girard R. Mensonge romantique et la vérité Romanesque [Romantic Lie & Romanesque Truth]. Paris, Grasset Publ., 1977, 305 p.

2. Girard R. Nasilie i svyashchennoe [Violence and the Sacred]. Moscow, Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie Publ., 2010, 433 p.

3. Girard R. Des choses cachées depuis la fondation du monde [Things Hidden since the Foundation of the World]. Paris, Grasset Publ., 1978, 605 p.

4. Girard R. Kozel otpushcheniya [The Scapegoat]. Moscow, Ivana Limbakha Publ., 2010, 336 p.

5. Tarde G. Zakony podrazhaniya [The Laws of Imitation]. Moscow, Akademicheskii Proekt Publ., 2011, 304 p.

6. Lorenz K. Agressiya, ili tak nazyvaemoe zlo [On Aggression]. Moscow, RIMIS Publ., 2009, 352 p.

7. Girard R. Les origines de la culture [The Origins of Culture]. Paris, Pluriel Publ., 2013, 280 p.

8. Girard R. La violence et le sacré [Violence and the Sacred]. Paris, Grasset Publ., 1972, 456 p.

9. Girard R. Kritika iz podpol’ya [The Criticism from the Underground]. Moscow, Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie Publ., 2013, 249 p.

10. Freud S. Totem i tabu [Totem and Taboo]. Tbilisi, Merani Publ., 1991, 396 p.

11. Durkheim É. Elementarnye formy religioznoi zhizni. Totemicheskaya sistema v Avstralii [The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. The Totemic System in Australia], Mistika. Religiya. Nauka: Klassiki mirovogo religiovedeniya: antologiya [Mysticism. Religion. Science: The Classics of World Religion Studies: Anthology]. Moscow, Kanon+ Publ., 1998, pp. 174—230.

12. Girard R. Les grands entretiens [The Big Interviews]. Paris, Artpress Publ., 2015, 108 p.

13. Dmitriev A.V., Sychev A.A. Skandal: Sotsiofilosofskie ocherki: monografiya [Scandal: Socio-Philosophical Essays: Monograph]. Moscow, TsSP i M Publ., 2014, 323 p.

14. Girard R. La voix meconnue du reel. Une theorie des mythes achaiques et modernes [The Unknown Voice of Reality. The Theory of Archaic and Modern Myths]. Paris, Grasset Publ., 2010, 304 p.

15. Artaud A. Teatr i ego dvoinik [The Theatre and its Double]. Moscow, Martis Publ., 1993, 189 p.

16. Leach E. Kul’tura i kommunikatsiya. Logika vzaimosvyazi simvolov: K ispol’zovaniyu strukturnogo analiza v sotsial’noi antropologii [Culture and Communication: The Logic by Which Symbols Are Connected]. Moscow, “Vostochnaya Literatura” RAN Publ., 2001,149 p.

17. Ostorero M., Anheim É. Le diable en procès [The Devil on Trial], Medievales. Available at: https://medievales.revues.org/988#tocto1n2 (accessed 26.09.2016).

18. Tarde G. Psikhologiya tolp. Mnenie i tolpa [Crowd Psychology. The Opinion and the Crowd]. Moscow, Institut Psikhologii RAN Publ., KSP+ Publ., 1999, 416 p.

19. Kopets L.V. Klassicheskie eksperimenty v psikhologii [Classic Experiments in Psychology], Psi-faktor. Available at: http://psyfactor.org/lib/experimenty_asha.htm (accessed 16.10.2016).

20. Karelin V. Opyt demaskirovki gonenii [An Essay at Demasquing Persecution], Filosofskii zhurnal [Philosophy Journal], 2011, no. 2. Available at: http://iph.ras.ru/uplfile/root/biblio/pj/pj_7/10.pdf (accessed 09.10.2016).

21. Dvorkin A. Massovyi rasstrel v Monreale: politika pola v ubiistve zhenshchin [The Montreal Massacre: The Gender Policy in Women’s Murder], Womenation.org: informatsionnyi zhurnal zhenskogo osvoboditel’nogo dvizheniya [The Information Journal of the Women’s Liberation Movement]. Available at: http://womenation.org/dworkin-mtl-massacre/ (accessed 15.10.2016).

22. The Colloquium on Violence and Religion. Available at: http://violenceandreligion.com/about (accessed 09.11.2016).