Titian and Lorenzo Lotto: From the History of Art Dialogue by the Example of the “Collector’s Portrait”

The article explores various aspects of the practice of collecting works of classical art in Renaissance Venice, as well as its influence on the content program formation of the so-called “Collector’s Portrait”, a typological kind of portraiture common in the art of the 16th century. The most interesting examples of it are the “Portrait of Andrea Odoni” by Lorenzo Lotto and the “Portrait of Jacopo Strada” by Titian, considered in this article. The study is relevant because of its connection with the research attention, outlined in recent decades, to the history of collecting, antique trade and the role of socio-economic factors in the development of art history. The article aims to investigate, on the basis of written sources, the matter of how the content of such paintings reflects the moral and ethical ideas about the meaning of antique collecting, as well as to identify its characteristic features on the Venetian grounds. One of the features was that a significant proportion of the artistic material in private collections was composed of works of Greek-Hellenistic art. The interest in collecting these works speaks about the special aesthetic predilections of collectors, their sensitivity to the actual artistic merits of antiques, and not only about their desire to possess antiquities. In addition, the practice of collecting was intended to express the moral virtues of the collector, the greatness of their spirit and the nobility of their thoughts. On the other hand, it served as an important way of social self-assertion for those who were not part of the exclusive elite of Venetian society (patricians), but sought to approach it in their social ambitions. First of all, the article is of interest to historians, art historians, culturologists, museum specialists and antique trade specialists.

theory and history of art, fine and decorative arts, art culture, Renaissance, Venice, collecting, gathering, antiquity, antiques, huma­nism, portrait, Lorenzo Lotto, Titian

1. Favaretto I. Arte antica e cultura antiquaria nelle collezioni venete al tempo della Serenissima. Rome, “L’Erma” di Bretschneider Publ., 2002, 414 p.

2. Venezia! Kunst aus venezianischen Palästen. Sammlungsgeschichte Venedigs vom 13. bis 19. Jahrhundert. Bonn, Hatje Cantz Publ., 2002, 415 p.

3. Gargan L. Oliviero Forzetta e la diffusione dei testi classici nel Veneto al tempo di Petrarca, Classical Influences on European Culture. A.D. 500—1500. Cambridge, University Press Publ., 1971, pp. 73—80.

4. Golovin V.P. Skul’ptura i zhivopis’ ital’yanskogo Vozrozhdeniya: vliyaniya i vzaimosvyaz [Sculpture and Painting of the Italian Renaissance: Their Influence and Relationship]. Moscow, MGU Publ., 1985, 103 p.

5. Yailenko E.V. Venetsianskaya antichnost’ [Venetian Antiquity]. Moscow, Novoe Literaturnoe Obozrenie Publ., 2010, 485 p.

6. Mommsen T. Über die berliner Excerptenhandschrift des Petrus Donates, Jahrbuch der königlich preussischen Kunstsammlungen, 1883, vol. 4, pp. 73—89.

7. Voigt G. Vozrozhdenie klassicheskoi drevnosti, ili pervyi vek gumanizma: v 2 t. [The Rebirth of Classical Antiquity, or the First Century of Humanism: in 2 volumes]. Moscow, K.T. Soldatenkova Publ., 1885, vol. 2. 540 p.

8. Weiss R. The Renaissance Discovery of Classical Antiquity. Oxford, Basil Blackwell Publ., 1988, 434 p.

9. Lazarev V.N. Mantegna, Starye ital’yanskie mastera [Old Italian Masters]. Moscow, Iskusstvo Publ., 1972, pp. 201—270 (in Russ.).

10. Brown C.M. “Una Testa de Platone Antica con la Punta dil Naso di Cera”: Unpublished Negotiations between Isabella d’Este and Niccolo and Giovanni Bellini, The Art Bulletin, 1969, vol. 51, no. 4, pp. 372—377.

11. Smirnova I.A. Yakopo Bellini i nachalo Vozrozhdeniya v Venetsii [Jacopo Bellini and the Beginning of the Renaissance in Venice]. Moscow, NII Teorii i istorii izobrazit. Iskusstv Publ., 1994, 270 p.

12. Bode W., Gronau L., Hadeln D. Archivalische Beiträge zur Geschichte der venezianischen Kunst. Berlin, B. Cassirer Publ., 1911, 206 p.

13. Sansovino F. Venezia, Città nobilissima et singolare. Venice, Appresso Stefano Curti Publ., 1663, 976 p.

14. Manutio P. Lettere volgari di Paolo Manutio, divise in quarto libri. Venice, Aldus Publ., 1560, 250 p.

15. Schmitter M. “Virtuous Riches”: The Bricolage in Cittadini Identities in Early Sixteenth-Century Venice, Renaissance Quarterly, 2004, vol. 57, no. 3, pp. 908—969.

16. Frimmel T. Der Anonimo Morelliano: (Marcanton Michiel’s Notizia d’opere del disegno). Vienna, G. Graese Publ., 1896, 166 p.

17. Brown D.A., Humfrey P., Lucco M. Lorenzo Lotto: rediscovered Master of the Renaissance. London, New Haven, Washington, National Gallery of Art Publ., Yale University Press. Publ., 1997, 248 p.

18. Ferino-Pagden S. (ed.) Late Titian and the Sensuality of Painting. Vienna, Marsilio Publ., 2007, 336 p.

19. Vasari G. Zhizneopisaniya naibolee znamenitykh zhivopistsev, vayatelei i zodchikh [Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects]. Moscow, Terra Publ., 1994, vol. 3. 816 p.